Claims

As a Trusted Choice Agency we strive to help you with all aspects of your insurance program. This includes claims on you policies. When at all possible we look to receiving claims directly from you. We ask this so that we can properly protect you. Sometimes it is not in your best interest over the long run to turn in a claim because of the size of the claim or of the frequency of claims. Turning in some claims can cost you more than the claim itself. We are here to answer such questions.

We endeavor to make ourselves available even when our office is closed. However, should an emergency crop up please use these numbers to reach our companies’ claims personnel:

Groendyke Associates 800-476-7466

Selective Insurance Company (SRI) 866-455-9969
Selective Flood has a direct claims number 877-348-0552

Allstate Insurance Company (ANJ) 800-255-7828

Franklin Mutual/FMI 800-842-0551 (option#2)

Farmers Mutual Insurance 800-842-5032

Palisades Insurance Group and
Plymouth Rock Assurance 877-725-6423 (877-PAL-NICE)

N J Skylands/One Beacon 866-279-7688

Chubb Insurance Group 800-252-4670

Utica National Insurance Group 800-216-1420

Preferred Mutual Insurance Co 800-333-7642

Western Surety/CNA 605-339-0060

Foremost Insurance Company 800-527-3907

FEMA (flood claims) 888-379-9531

Tower Insurance 888-856-5522

Peerless Insurance 800-522-7152

Hartford Insurance 800-327-3636